What Is a Fiduciary Financial Advisor?
What fiduciary duty actually requires, who has it and who does not, and how to verify an adviser's status.
Read the fiduciary guide
The 2024 DOL Retirement Security Rule was vacated before it took effect. On March 18, 2026, the Department of Labor announced its removal and the restoration of ERISA's prior five-part test. That does not remove every fiduciary duty or broker obligation. This guide explains the current distinction between ERISA fiduciary status, investment adviser duties and Regulation Best Interest.
One rule, one goal: make a one-time rollover recommendation legally require your best interest.
The 2024 DOL Retirement Security Rule would have expanded fiduciary coverage for certain compensated professional retirement recommendations, including some one-time rollover advice. It did not cover everyone who discusses retirement. A fiduciary must meet legal duties to the people they advise. Federal courts vacated the rule, and the DOL removed it in 2026 before it took effect. Its history helps explain which rules apply to retirement advice today.
In April 2024, the Department of Labor finalized the Retirement Security Rule (opens in new tab). It would have expanded fiduciary coverage for compensated retirement recommendations made in specified professional circumstances. Some one-time rollover or annuity recommendations could have qualified. The rule did not make every retirement conversation fiduciary advice.
The older regulation dates to 1975 and uses a five-part test. One condition is advice given "on a regular basis." A one-time rollover recommendation does not automatically satisfy that test; the relationship and all five conditions matter. Separate investment-adviser or brokerage duties may still apply. The 2024 rule sought to expand coverage beyond that existing test.
Trade groups sued almost right away, arguing the Department of Labor didn't have the legal authority to write the rule this way. It was the same argument that killed the DOL's previous attempt: the 2016 fiduciary rule, struck down by a federal appeals court (the Fifth Circuit) in 2018.
Courts blocked it before it took effect and later entered final judgments vacating it.
In mid-2024, two federal courts in Texas put the rule on hold nationwide before its start date. The Retirement Security Rule never applied to a single person. It just sat frozen while the lawsuits played out.
The Department's March 18, 2026 release (opens in new tab) reports final judgments in two federal district courts vacating the 2024 rule and related exemption amendments. DOL removed the vacated provisions and restored ERISA's five-part test. Its Retirement Security Rule page (opens in new tab) carries the vacatur notice.
The DOL has made several attempts to revise this definition. The 2016 rule was vacated in 2018; the 2024 rule was blocked before taking effect and later vacated. The March 18, 2026 release says DOL had no current notice-and-comment rulemaking plans. Check current DOL guidance because future rulemaking or litigation can change the position.
Older guides can mislead. Courts also vacated two earlier DOL positions on rollover advice: the FAQ 7 policy, in February 2023, and portions of the PTE 2020-02 preamble, in July 2025. DOL's March 20, 2026 Federal Register notice (opens in new tab) says: "Even though PTE 2020-02 has remained operative, its preamble is no longer reliable due to the courts' vacaturs in the 2022 litigation." In plain words, the exemption still exists, but an older article that quotes its preamble to explain rollover advice may describe a position that no longer stands. Check the date on anything you read about this rule. This is general information, not legal advice.
Focused portfolio management with a human adviser
Narstar manages four model portfolios for different goals and risk tolerances, with direct access to the adviser making the decisions. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.
Three kinds of professional, three different rules, plus one retirement-law test. None of them wear a label that tells you which one applies.
Under retirement law, the restored five-part test determines when investment advice creates ERISA fiduciary status. A one-time recommendation alone generally does not satisfy its regular-basis requirement. The person's relationship with you and the facts still matter; do not assume that every rollover recommendation is outside fiduciary rules.
Broker-dealers have Regulation Best Interest obligations when they recommend a securities transaction or investment strategy to a retail customer, including relevant rollover recommendations. That standard is distinct from an investment adviser's fiduciary duty. A professional may also act in more than one capacity, so ask which capacity applies to the specific recommendation.
Insurance agents selling annuities operate under applicable insurance laws and product rules. The standard can depend on the state and the recommendation. Ask about the applicable duty, product costs and any commission rather than inferring fiduciary status from a job title.
Registered investment advisers still owe fiduciary duties under the law that governs their registration. SEC-registered firms are governed by federal law. State-registered firms, including Narstar, are governed by applicable state law and rules. Narstar's duty does not depend on the 2024 DOL rule, so the court decisions did not remove it.
It's back on you to figure out which rule applies.
The exact same sentence, "you should roll that old 401(k) into an IRA," can come from a broker, an insurance agent, or a registered investment adviser. Each one follows a different rule and gets paid a different way. After the 2024 rule was vacated, the 1975 five-part test again governs fiduciary status under federal retirement law. A job title alone will not tell you which rule applies.
That doesn't mean every rollover recommendation is bad advice. Plenty of them are fine. But now it's on you to check. Two questions do most of the work: are you a fiduciary for this specific recommendation, and how do you get paid if I follow it? Anyone acting in good faith can answer both without dodging. Hesitation is an answer too.
If you're weighing a rollover right now, the step-by-step rollover guide covers the mechanics, the tax traps, and the mistakes that actually cost money.
You don't need to wait for a regulation, because the public records already exist.
Start with the SEC's free public lookup tool: adviserinfo.sec.gov (opens in new tab). Type in the name of anyone giving you retirement advice and you can see whether they're actually registered as an investment adviser, plus read their official disclosure document (it's called Form ADV Part 2A). Then just ask them, in writing, whether they're acting as your fiduciary for this specific recommendation. None of that depends on who's running the Department of Labor.
Narstar is a fee-only registered investment adviser, registered in Utah and conditionally registered in Texas. We're not a brokerage and we don't earn commissions. Our fiduciary duty comes from securities law and our state registration, not from a DOL rule that can vanish overnight, and it applies to every account we manage, including rollover IRAs held at Interactive Brokers. Narstar manages four model portfolios that clients get matched to: Income, Trend, Growth, and Speculative. That fiduciary duty doesn't make investing safe. Any of these portfolios can lose money. It just means the advice has to be about what's good for you, not what's good for us. You can look up our own public record, ID number CRD #337496 (opens in new tab), and run the same checks on us first.
What the vacated rule means for your retirement money, answered directly.
No. The 2024 Retirement Security Rule was vacated before it took effect. DOL announced its removal and restoration of ERISA's prior five-part test on March 18, 2026. Other retirement rules and professional obligations remain. Future rulemaking or litigation can change this position.
A one-time rollover recommendation alone generally does not satisfy the regular-basis requirement in ERISA's restored five-part test. The facts and existing advice relationship still matter. A broker-dealer may have Regulation Best Interest obligations for the recommendation, and a professional acting as an investment adviser has separate fiduciary duties.
Registered investment advisers owe fiduciary duties under the law that governs their registration. SEC-registered firms are governed by federal law. State-registered firms, including Narstar, are governed by applicable state law and rules. No DOL rule created Narstar's duty, and vacating the 2024 DOL rule did not remove it.
Look them up for free at adviserinfo.sec.gov (opens in new tab) and see whether they're registered as an investment adviser. Then just ask them directly: are you a fiduciary for this specific recommendation, and how do you get paid if I follow it? Both questions have straight answers. If they hesitate or dodge, that tells you something too.
If you're trying to figure out which standard applies to advice you've been given, or what working with a fee-only fiduciary adviser would look like, send the question. We'll reply. The fee calculator estimates your Narstar advisory fee at any balance. Interactive Brokers charges separate brokerage commissions and fees.