Skip to main content

IPO Investing: Risks, Lockups and What to Check

Hands cutting a red ribbon with scissors on a wooden table

An initial public offering, or IPO, is a company's first sale of shares to the public. Buying at the offering price is different from buying after trading begins. Before buying, check the prospectus, how shares are allocated, any lockup terms and the company's financial disclosures. A first-day price rise does not establish a stock's long-term value or make it suitable for you.

What Actually Happens on IPO Day

The pop you read about mostly isn't available to you.

The banks that run an IPO, called underwriters, set the price and decide who gets shares first. They give most of the shares to their biggest clients before regular people can place an order. The SEC's own investor bulletin on IPOs (opens in new tab) says the same thing: underwriters typically hand most shares to mutual funds, hedge funds, pension funds, insurance companies, and wealthy individuals. Most people never get a shot at buying at the actual IPO price.

That gap between the IPO price and where the stock opens for regular trading is called underpricing, and it shows up in the numbers every year. According to Jay Ritter's University of Florida IPO database (opens in new tab), the average U.S. IPO from 1980 through 2025 jumped 19.0% on its first day of trading, across 9,343 deals. In 2025 alone, the average first-day jump was 29.3%. That gain goes to whoever already held shares at the IPO price, mostly the big investors above. If you buy after the stock opens, you're buying after that jump already happened, not before it.

Underwriters can also prop up the price for the first few days by buying shares themselves, which keeps it from falling too far below the IPO price early on. The SEC says it plainly: "Once this support ends, the stock price may decline significantly below the offering price." A strong first week doesn't mean the market has actually figured out what the company is worth.

Why the Company's Numbers Are Thinner Than They Look

A new public company has less checked, audited history than almost anything else you can buy.

Some IPO issuers qualify as emerging growth companies under SEC rules. The SEC's IPO investor bulletin (opens in new tab) describes a revenue threshold of less than $1.235 billion and other eligibility conditions. That status can continue for up to five fiscal years after the IPO unless a disqualifying event occurs. Qualifying issuers can use certain reduced disclosure requirements, including two years of audited financial statements in the IPO prospectus instead of three.

A prospectus is a regulatory filing that describes the offering, finances and risks. Reduced disclosure does not mean the financial statements are unaudited. After the IPO, reporting companies file quarterly Forms 10-Q and annual Forms 10-K. Quarterly financial statements generally are unaudited, while annual financial statements include an audit report. Check the actual filing and the issuer's reporting status.

That thinner record runs into a second problem on IPO day: most of the company's shares can't even be sold yet.

The 180-Day Lockup, and Why the Expiration Date Matters

People inside the company can't sell right away. When they finally can, a lot of shares can hit the market at once.

The shares trading at first are generally the IPO shares, while many other outstanding shares are restricted or locked up. Lockup agreements commonly limit sales by founders, employees and early investors for a period that is often 180 days. Terms vary, so read the prospectus rather than assuming a universal expiration date.

What happens when the lockup expires matters, because a lot of shares can become sellable on the very same day. The SEC's own guidance is blunt about the risk: "when lock-up agreements expire, the share price may decline significantly if a large number of shares become available for sale all at once." Early investors and employees often see the IPO as their first real chance to cash out, and the lockup expiration is when that chance finally arrives.

This isn't just a warning in a government pamphlet. Academic research backs it up. A study of 1,948 share lockup agreements (Field, L.C. and Hanka, G. (2001), "The Expiration of IPO Share Lockups," The Journal of Finance, 56(2): 471-500 (opens in new tab)) found that once the lockup expired, trading volume rose by a permanent 40%, and the stock's price fell by a statistically significant 1.5% on average over the three days around the expiration date. The effect was even bigger at venture-capital-backed companies, where the study found VCs sold more aggressively than executives and other shareholders once they were free to.

The study reports an average for its historical sample, not a rule for every stock or a forecast. Check the actual lockup terms and possible share supply. Waiting until a date passes does not guarantee a lower price or a safer investment.

What Historical IPO Data Can Tell You

The average newly public stock falls behind the market for years. Some kinds of IPOs fall behind by a lot more.

Jay Ritter's long-run IPO report (opens in new tab), dated October 5, 2026, reports 9,253 qualifying U.S. IPOs from 1980 through 2024. In Table 16, their average buy-and-hold return from the first-day closing price was 20.5 percentage points below the market benchmark and 8.9 points below size-and-value-matched firms. The horizon ends at three years, delisting, or the data cutoff, whichever comes first. These are cumulative return differences, not annual returns.

The results vary by issuer characteristics. In that sample, issuers with pre-issue sales below $100 million, measured in 2025 dollars, averaged 34.3 percentage points below the market benchmark. Issuers with negative trailing twelve-month earnings per share averaged 30.7 points below it. These are separate historical group averages, not forecasts for any company.

Table 16a groups issuers by pre-issue sales, without requiring profitability. Those with at least $1 billion in sales, measured in 2025 dollars, averaged 0.6 percentage points above matched firms and 2.1 points below the market benchmark. The comparison illustrates how outcomes varied across groups. It does not establish that larger companies guarantee a better investment.

The sample excludes several categories, including IPOs priced below $5, ADRs, REITs, and certain financial issuers. It is not a census of every IPO. Returns start at the first-day closing price, and recent cohorts have shorter follow-up through the report's cutoff. Historical averages do not predict an individual stock's return; losses can be substantial.

Focused portfolio management with a human adviser

Want someone to manage your investments?

Narstar manages four model portfolios for different goals and risk tolerances, with direct access to the adviser making the decisions. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.

Ask a Question See the Portfolios

What to Actually Check Before You Buy

Wait until there's a real track record, then look at it.

Wait past the lockup. The company has to disclose the lockup's end date in the prospectus, usually under a heading called "Shares Eligible for Future Sale." Watch how the stock trades once that supply is actually free to sell, instead of guessing ahead of time.

Compare the prospectus with later filings. Quarterly Forms 10-Q can show how the company performs after the offering, and annual Forms 10-K provide audited annual financial statements. One or two reports do not establish a reliable performance history, but they can help you test the assumptions behind an investment decision.

Watch what insiders do once the lockup ends. How much stock insiders actually sell once they're free to, compared to how much they keep, tells you something real: whether the people who know the business best are sticking around at this price.

Check which disclosure requirements apply. Emerging growth company status can last up to five fiscal years after an IPO unless a disqualifying event occurs. It can permit two years of audited financial statements instead of three, along with other reduced disclosure and auditor-attestation requirements. That does not mean the IPO financial statements are unaudited. Read the prospectus to see which accommodations the issuer uses.

How Narstar Approaches New Public Companies

We buy based on a company's numbers, not the hype around its first day of trading.

None of Narstar's four model portfolios chase a company's first days as a public stock. The Growth portfolio holds companies with a real, lasting edge over their competitors, and that takes years of results to prove. The Income portfolio holds dividend-paying companies picked for their cash flow, and a company can't show a track record of paying dividends on day one. The Speculative portfolio does take on real risk in smaller, less established companies, but that's a different kind of risk than what this article covers: a 180-day lockup and thinner disclosure that both fade once a company has a real track record.

A taxable account with one model portfolio pays 0.60% annually for Income, 1.00% for Trend, 1.20% for Growth, or 1.60% for Speculative. A taxable account with two or more model portfolios pays 1.00% on the whole account, including cash. Traditional, Roth, Rollover, SEP, SIMPLE, and inherited IRA accounts all use the uniform 1.00% annual IRA rate on the whole account, regardless of model portfolio mix. Fees are billed quarterly in arrears. All four carry real risk: stocks fall, companies fail, trends reverse suddenly, and dividends are never guaranteed. What's happened before doesn't tell you what will happen next, and Interactive Brokers may charge its own separate brokerage fees on top of what you pay us.

Common Questions About IPO Investing

The questions worth asking before you buy a newly public stock.

Isn't getting into a hot IPO the whole point, buying in early before everyone else?

Usually not for regular investors. The banks running the IPO hand most of the shares to big investors and wealthy clients before the stock ever opens to the public, and the average U.S. IPO has jumped 19.0% on its first day of trading since 1980 (29.3% in 2025 alone), according to Jay Ritter's University of Florida IPO database. If you buy after the stock opens, you're usually buying after that jump, not before it.

What exactly is a lockup period, and why does it matter to me?

A lockup is a promise, usually lasting 180 days per the SEC's investor bulletin on IPOs, that keeps a company's founders, employees, and early investors from selling their shares right after the IPO. Generally, only the shares sold in the IPO trade at first. When the lockup ends, a lot of extra shares can hit the market at once, and the SEC says the price may drop a lot because of it.

Does an IPO stock always drop after the lockup expires?

No. It's a documented tendency, not a rule for every stock. A study of 1,948 share lockup agreements (Field, L.C. and Hanka, G. (2001), The Journal of Finance, 56(2): 471-500 (opens in new tab)) found a statistically significant average price decline of 1.5% over the three days around the expiration date, along with a permanent 40% jump in trading volume. Some stocks absorb the new supply with little visible impact. The average effect is real; it isn't universal.

So is there ever a good time to buy a newly public stock?

There is no universal waiting period that makes an IPO a good investment. Review the prospectus, company finances, valuation, share-sale restrictions and later filings. Consider whether the risk fits your circumstances. Neither a first-day rise nor the end of a lockup guarantees a favorable result.

Can you lose money on an IPO?

Yes. The SEC's investor bulletin on IPOs (opens in new tab) says IPOs can be risky and speculative investments. It notes that shares can close well above or below the offering price shortly after the IPO, and that once the underwriters stop supporting the price, it may decline significantly below the offering price. If you buy after a first-day jump, you can lose money even if the stock stays above its IPO price. You can lose some or all of what you invest.

Have Questions About a Specific IPO?

Wondering whether a specific newly public company fits your goals? Get in touch.

Fields marked with * are required.

0 / 1,000

We read every message and reply, usually within two business days. No commitment, and no spam.